VCAT expert witness reports

A formal expert report for proceedings in VCAT's Building and Property List. It sets out what was observed, the standard each item departs from, the expert's opinion and the work needed to fix it, with the declarations the Tribunal requires.

Who it's for

  • Homeowners bringing or defending a building claim
  • Builders and trades responding to a claim
  • Solicitors and counsel acting for any party

What's assessed

  • Alleged defects, inspected and measured on site
  • Compliance with the contract, plans and specifications supplied
  • The National Construction Code and relevant Australian Standards
  • Workmanship against accepted tolerances
  • Whether an item is a defect, maintenance or a matter of taste

What you receive

  • A numbered schedule of defects with photographs
  • Severity rating for each item against stated criteria
  • Opinions confined to the expert's area of expertise
  • A specific rectification scope for each item
  • The expert's qualifications, independence statement and declaration

Typical process

  1. Enquiry and conflict check. We confirm we haven't acted for another party in the matter.
  2. Initial matter review. We review your documents and photos and identify the issues.
  3. Scope and fee proposal. Written scope, fixed fee and delivery date before work begins.
  4. Inspection and report. Site inspection, then the report delivered by the agreed date.
Worth knowing

An expert's overriding duty is to assist the Tribunal impartially. The report is the expert's own opinion, whichever party pays for it. Attendance at a compulsory conference, expert conclave or hearing is not included in the report fee. It's charged separately and confirmed in writing before the attendance date.

Request an assessment